Christmas Family Murders: In the Still of the Night

On the night of Wednesday, February 7, 1906, in a sleepy town in Florida a shocking crime shattered the stillness. Three members of the Christmas family were brutally murdered in their own home, each struck in the head with an axe before their throats were slit. 

Case File Quick Facts:

• Victims: J.M. Christmas (60), Martha Christmas (49), Slocum Christmas (10)
• Location: Campbellton, Jackson County, Florida
• Date: February 7, 1906
• Classification: Historical Homicide / Domestic Axe Murder
• Current Status: Unsolved / Cold Case
• Perpetrator Status: Son William Christmas arrested and tried, found not guilty

Located in the the Florida panhandle, the town of Campbellton, was barely a “map dot” of two to three hundred people in 1906. It began as a settlement around 1840, but wasn’t officially established until 1925. It was, and still is a quiet, rural community. The landscape is a mixture of farmland and dense pine and hardwood forests.

In 1906, one of Campbellton’s more prominent citizens was Jeremy M. (J.M.) Christmas. He was well known in the area, a Civil War veteran, and people considered him a man of means. He owned a business and also worked as a judge. J.M. and his wife Martha shared 13 children, seven of whom died before the age of 10. By 1906, four of their surviving children were adults and lived with their own families. Their 19-year-old son Joseph was away at school. Their youngest surviving child, 10-year-old son Slocum Gunger, still lived at home.

Christmas Family Murders: In their Own Home

On February 8, 1906, Mr. Christmas failed to appear for a planned appointment. Concerned, a few friends went by his residence to check on him. Upon entering the home, they discovered a horrific scene. J.M., Martha, and young Slocum were found dead in the room where they all slept, lying in puddles of blood. The killer had beaten their heads with the blunt end of an axe and slit their throats. They had been beaten so severely that their heads were almost severed from their bodies. The attack was brutal and a clear case of overkill. 

Police originally considered the motive to be robbery, but nothing seemed to be missing from the home. A safe in the hallway was not touched. In the room where the murders occurred, several dollars were laid out on a table, untouched. The bloody murder weapon, an axe belonging to the family, was found in the front yard of the home.

Panic engulfed the small community. Citizen posses were formed to find the killers. Within a month of the murders, several families relocated, citing fear as their reason. Newspapers called for blood, reporting, “Anger in the neighborhood is at a white heat, and no stone is being left unturned that might aid in the work of detection.” ¹Anniston Star 2/11/1906

“I have an idea about this thing, but of course I can’t afford to speak of it. I might do some man a terrible injustice.” – Local resident to Montgomery Advertiser March 7, 1906

Police Work in the Early 20th Century:

As you can imagine, early 1900s police work was vastly different than today. A community such as Campbellton would not have had its own police force. They would have to rely on the county sheriff, if there was one, or perhaps a town marshal. Those people would not be well trained, if at all, in conducting investigations of this magnitude. Houston County Sheriff Crawford, from just over the state line in Alabama, arrived in town the day after the bodies were found. He was there to assist Marianna Sheriff H.H. Lewis in the investigation. Bloodhounds were sent for, a common occurrence at the time. Unfortunately, a prolonged rain hampered their efforts. Several unnamed people were arrested following the murders, but all were able to provide an alibi.

Private investigators were common in more urban areas but not always reliable or trustworthy. They would travel to areas like rural Florida, usually to try and receive reward money. Author Bill James says they worked mostly as spies. They’d come to a town, try and infiltrate the local criminal element, and cash in on any information they’d been able to gather. By no stretch of the imagination could their methods be called scientific.

A Preposterous Plot

One such investigator, a man named W.C. Franklin, arrived in Campbellton from Chicago shortly after the murders. A reward of $2,500 ($93,000 in 2026) had been offered for information on the triple homicide. Franklin concocted a plan that can only be described as absolutely absurd. He hid out in woods near Campbellton and pretended to be an escaped prisoner from Georgia on the run from the law. He hired a Black man, John Justice, to bring him meals. The man would deliver the food on a donkey. Franklin had convinced himself that the man knew something about the murders, so he persuaded a ventriloquist friend to hide in the woods and “speak” for the donkey. Justice was reportedly so shocked by the donkey speaking in a human voice that he immediately fell to the ground and confessed to the triple murder. He also implicated the Christmas’ oldest son, William, and one of their sons-in-law, Walter, in his “confession.” This story was all according to W.C. Franklin.

The “investigator” and ventriloquist went to the sheriff with this outlandish tale. Inexplicably, the sheriff believed the story and on March 13, 1906, arrested William Christmas, Walter Holland, his wife Cordelia (the Christmas family’s second oldest child), along with John and Jasper Justice, the food delivery man and his father. ²

Dubious Tactics

As you can likely gather, back then the police could arrest someone just because they felt like it. They didn’t always require things like proof or evidence. In the post-Civil War South, Black people, especially Black men, were affected by disproportionately high arrest rates. Some estimates say that between 1880 and 1928, approximately one in every three Black men had been arrested at some point in their lives. The charges were often baseless, at times even fabricated. 

The “talking donkey” story was reported in newspapers as far away as Indiana and California. William was released on bail on May 10, 1906. Walter Holland was released on bail a few days later. Cordelia was released from jail, although it is not specified when. John and Jasper Justice were kept in prison; it is unclear when they were released, if at all.

William, who had married a local woman named Minnie Buntin the year before, is the only one who would eventually be tried for the Christmas family murders. Authorities had discovered another piece of evidence against him besides the word of a terrified man who thought a donkey was speaking—a bloody shirt. 

A Bloody Shirt is Found

In an April 1906 article, the Birmingham News reported that the shirt’s location was revealed to a local man in a dream.

“A man who had been endeavoring to ferret out the crime and bring the guilty party to justice and who had spent many sleepless nights in trying to solve the mystery had a dream that the shirt of the man who killed the Christmas family was hidden in the attic of an old building in the neighborhood. The next morning he got a rake, went to the house in question, went in the garret and between the ceiling of the two floors he raked out this shirt, which corresponded in color with the cuffs found in William Christmas’s trunk, the shirt of which was missing.”

Other reports state that the bloody shirt was found in the loft of the Christmas Family’s store. A man named W.L. McKinley testified in William’s trial that that’s where he found it. William’s explanation was that he had worn it while slaughtering a pig and left it at the store because his wife did not like to see blood. William declined to answer when questioned about the whereabouts of the pig.

A New Will Comes to Light

A few days before the murders, J.M. Christmas wrote a letter to his son, Joseph. In it, he asked him to come take over the family business ²It was not reported what kind of store, or for that matter, what type of business J.M. Christmas owned. from William. J.M. accused William of being too “wild and reckless” and of squandering the business’ money. In addition to this damning letter, J.M. had written a new will, which cut William off almost entirely. 

A reportedly bloody copy of the new will was found at the office of the probate judge, three weeks after the murders. It was speculated that William originally intended on destroying the new will, but instead mailed it to the probate judge, since people in the area knew J.M. had changed it recently. The new will, authorities decided, was the catalyst for the axe murders. It does seem bizarre that William would kill his parents and younger brother in order to destroy the new will but then end up sending it to the court anyway. There’s no way to know if this actually happened or not.

The details of the original will are unknown, but if the estate was evenly divided, William would have had to share the proceeds with his four surviving siblings, Carrie, Cordelia, Alice, and Joseph. It was not reported whether William actually retained control over his father’s business, if it was passed to Joseph, or if the two shared ownership.

Ambiguous Evidence 

Other evidence against William was an alleged assassination attempt on Joseph, days before the murders. Having honored his father’s plea to return home and take over the business, Joseph was shot at three times. Miraculously, every bullet missed. The perpetrators were never caught, and this charge was not mentioned in the trial records. Shortly after the murders, one of William’s sisters accused him publicly, though which sister made the claim remains unknown.

William’s reaction to the murders was also called into question. While the coroner was in the room with the bodies, William walked in, walked through the blood on the floor, and calmly rolled a cigarette and began smoking it. While it is unfair to judge how a person reacts to a loved one’s death, this does seem like a cold response.

An Unreliable Witness Tells her Story

An accounting of a witness to the murders was given in the Birmingham News. A woman, who said she lived in the home with the Christmas family, claimed she heard the killers come into the home. Terrified, she hid under her bed. She heard both J.M. and Martha call William by name. It is unclear if the killers brought lights into the home or if there was a lamp kept burning at the home.

The killer, who was either John or Jasper, struck J.M. with the axe first. When Martha pleaded for her life, causing the attacker to hesitate, William allegedly drew a pistol and threatened his accomplice to continue the killings. Slocum was then killed in his bed, having never woken up. The bodies were covered with their bed sheets before the killers left the home. 

However, this account raises several questions. It doesn’t explain the multiple axe blows or the victims’ slit throats described in other reports. In addition, this version of events is absent from other contemporary newspaper accounts and is not mentioned in a later trial synopsis. It’s unclear if this story is true or an embellished tale by a newspaper seeking to boost sales.

The Trial Starts

William Daniel Christmas went to trial on November 19, 1906. Witnesses recalled hearing the sound of a horse on the road leading to the Christmas family home on the night of the murders. Buggy tracks were discovered near the house, but Jim Brown, a longtime neighbor, reported seeing only a horse and rider—no buggy in sight. Brown, despite knowing William for years and having sufficient light to do so, was unable to identify the rider as William.

Christmas’ attorney, Mr. Price, threw doubt on the blood-spattered will and the bloody shirt. Both had been taken by Sheriff Crawford for further testing. The shirt went to Jacksonville, Florida, but no results were submitted to the court. The will went to New Orleans, Louisiana, but again, no results were submitted. The coroner’s jury, which was impaneled the day after the murders, had opened the safe and gone through every piece of paperwork inside. If the will was indeed bloody, surely they would have put it in their final report, per Price.

“It was said that Christmas could not be guilty, because he sung and whistled the night before the commission of the crime, but is that any evidence more than he was singularly cool and calculating? Did not Nero fiddle while Rome burned…” – Mr. Wilson, Prosecutor

The jury, made up of 12 white men, deliberated for 60 hours. A mistrial was declared on November 26, 1906. The final distribution of J.M. Christmas’ assets are unknown. It is unclear if the will was the original or the new one.

Aftermath of the Christmas Family Murders

Cordelia, who shared five children with her husband W.L. Pilcher, passed away in September 1906, before the murder trial. After being acquitted, William continued to live in the Campbellton area until the mid-1930s, when he and his wife, Minnie, moved to Miami, Florida. He passed away on September 29, 1941, after a long illness. He was survived by Minnie, two of their daughters, and his brother Joseph. William was buried at the Woodlawn Park North Cemetery and Mausoleum in Miami.

J.M., Martha and Slocum are all buried at the Howard Family Cemetery in Campbellton, Florida.

The Christmas family murders remain unsolved to this day, more than a century later. 

More Carnage

The Christmas family murders were not the only brutal axe murders committed that decade. Several similar massacres had occurred in the southeastern United States and beyond. 

Nine members of the Acreman family were killed with an axe in Allentown, Florida, on May 14, 1906. 

Five members of the Lyerly family were killed in Barber Junction, NC, on July 14, 1906. 

Six members of the Moore family, along with two visiting members of the Stillinger family, were murdered in Villisca, Iowa, on June 9, 1912.

Between May 1918 and October 1919, six people were killed and six more injured in the New Orleans, Louisiana area by the infamous Axeman. 

The Man from the Train

Authors Bill James and Rachel McCarthy James connected over 50 separate incidents of axe murders of families to one man in their book, The Man from The Train. These include all of the axe murders mentioned above, with the exception of the Axeman of New Orleans. Their suspect, a German immigrant named Paul Mueller disappeared into Germany sometime after 1922.

The Christmas Family murders do not quite fit this theme however. In 1906, Campbellton was at least 10-14 miles from the nearest train station. The Atlanta & St. Andrews Bay Railway (Bay Line) didn’t complete its track through Campbellton until 1908.

*Author’s Note: If you read anything about this case you’ll see that it supposedly took place in Cottonwood, Alabama, which is right over the Florida/Alabama state line. This is incorrect. A direct descendant of the Christmas family reached out to me to clarify that the murders actually look place in Campbellton, Florida, approximately 10 miles from Cottonwood. Jeremiah and Martha never lived in Cottonwood. Joseph lived there and would go one to raise his family there.

Share This